Lucy Hamilton
The Monocultural Cinematic Universe
Karl Stefanovic has been dumped by Channel 9 for platforming far-right figure Tommy Robinson on his podcast. The timing feels convenient. The longtime morning TV host now conjures darker forces on his independent right-wing show — and appears ready to harness the ‘cancellation’ backlash to fuel his next chapter.
In the aftermath of the announcement, One Nation leader Pauline Hanson — Stefanovic’s maiden podcast guest — publicly backed him, saying he had put his head on the chopping block at Nine. “Bloody stupid to do it,” she said. “They have no understanding. They’ve gone so far to the left, Channel Nine, they’re making a big mistake.” Hanson’s staunch defence underscored the growing alignment between Stefanovic’s new platform and One Nation’s populist surge.
UK based Piers Morgan, who carelessly and inaccurately endorsed Stefanovic as the “Australia’s biggest TV star,” praised the move as a bold stand for free speech, saying Karl was “finally speaking truth to power,” positioning him as a fellow warrior against “woke media censorship.” Together with Hanson’s backing, the international endorsement gives Karl’s rebrand a powerful boost: one that signals his shift from Australian tabloid host to a figure welcomed in the global right-wing media ecosystem.
While major outlets, from the publicly funded ABC to the Murdoch hounds at Sky News Australia generated ‘Karl Kontent’, a newly formed Camp Stefanovic — featuring Rebel News agitator Avi Yemini (who once told Robinson he was a “Jewish Nazi”), centrist clout-chaser Drew Pavlou, and even Elon Musk — began developing a narrative around Karl being cancelled. Being forced outside of the mainstream is a favoured position for former legacy-media-cum-edgelord-truth-tellers, made more pronounced with a plug from the world’s first trillionaire. Karl got his ‘cancelled’ stamp.
There is a formula and a copycat aspect to Stefanovic’s leap of faith into the podcasting world, something that can be seen from his set design alone. Karl’s show looks like a tacky remake of Tucker Carlson’s already reasonably tacky pastiche. Wood grain and good-quality farm wear are readily seen on set; even Stefanovic’s font is written in the style of a Texas steakhouse. But Stefanovic lacks the intelligence and charisma of Carlson, who pivoted with his clout as one of America’s most recognised and influential conservative figures, and used that starpower to establish a platform forged more by his authentic thoughts and positions.
Carlson has platformed a range of preeminent guests, from geopolitical realists breaking orthodox narratives on the Ukraine and Iran wars to Christian Palestinians speaking on their treatment. Karl, who sells himself as the man of the people and champion of the everyday Aussie battler, is so far giving softball interviews to former PMs John Howard and Tony Abbott, the human sausage Barnaby Joyce, political figures like Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, Alex Antic, Matt Canavan, Clive Palmer and Bob Katter, plus Kyle Sandilands and food tech-scam artist Pete Evans. No nuance, no challenging conversations, no personal discovery — all roads run to far-right narratives piped by billionaires.
A cinematic universe of overfed and overpaid media hacks is gathering — assembling with online grifters and sanitised with Karl’s charms — to shift the political debate further right, to where power wants it. Decades of woke-minded Australians, urged to resist human suffering and brutality, are no longer being convinced, and Karl’s pod is one of the new vehicles the powerful hope will use to drive the national debate into a much more hateful, confused and ineffective state of mind.
The legacy media now have their Pauline Hanson for clickbait over the next two years, but they also have ready access to the best bits of Karl — the controversial quotes and lines they can pull at will. The press can now call on the Monocultural Cinematic Universe, the MCU, and assemble Karl and Kyle, Hughsie, and the rest of the salt-and-peppered millionaire Avengers, to whine and wail. They are supported by a rung of b-tier figures in the extended universe, like immigrant agitators Rukshan Fernando, Avi Yemini, and Drew Pavlou, who all join the fury, defending genocides, speaking about deporting Muslims, but saying nothing about our ultra-powerful corporate elite and its compromised political arm larping as a steward of the people.
Now Karl may just be having a mid-life crisis and authentically taking a crack at interviewing a very select group of guests who happen to align politically and ideologically. But talk of his podcast being funded by Gina Rinehart, combined with plugs from the online right, and now Piers Morgan, points toward a more coordinated and global media product: one that isn’t being run out of Karl’s garage with a few cameras and a mic. Stefanovic probably won’t win the hearts of big international audiences, but that’s not his job. His real role is to act as a conduit for the more divisive, paranoid, and fear-mongering international narratives flooding this country – and he appears to have the full backing of those who wish him well.
There are currently only a few fringe independents willing to talk exclusively about grief farming, cooker theories, denigrating migrant communities, and pro-Zionist/billionaire garbage, and most established independent online media on the left and right can smell a phoney from a mile off. Karl didn’t start a podcast about planting a veggie patch or a Piers Morgan-style debate program — he went straight to the slop.
Karl represents a glaring fact: you don’t have to be politically astute, intelligent, empathetic, or cogent to become a mouthpiece for the new fringe caravan being towed behind the right-wing jalopy in Australia. Anyone prepared to work with the ideas of the powerful and maintain their superstructure gets lifted up on wings of the algorithm, propelled by botfarms of power and influence. Due to the fact that most of the people in the country have had just about a gutful of everyone, from the billionaire class, to the duopolies, to the political parties that act as the protection arm of the protection racket, there aren’t many left to pick up their mantle. Karl is a high profile recruit, but also venturing into unknown territory that craves authenticity
For over a decade Karl has defined the lines of acceptable debate from the centre and moved them as he saw fit. On the left he failed to recognise the struggle or suffering of people amid the recent carnage overseas; on the right he championed mandated vaccines and engineered narratives from above as part of the broken system. Stefanovic isn’t some marginalised edgelord — he is a TV man from Australia who hogged the limelight in a small ecosystem and rose to become one of its most handsomely remunerated figures. It will take him some while to shake that reputation. Karl is the establishment, and no ranch-style font on his logo, brand new RM Williams workwear, or farted-out colloquialisms will conceal his soft hands or his shallow heart.
Subscribe to The Shot
The Shot newsletter is the best way to keep up-to-date with the independent outlet without having to scroll through the hell of social media.
The Sunday Shot
The Shot’s Jo Dyer and Dave Milner are joined each week by a roster of Australia’s best independent journalists and thinkers to discuss what’s been happening this week in politics.
Advertisement
